I'd love to tell you that the first time I met John Wilcox, I knew that we would be lifelong friends. But what's closer to the truth is that the first time I met John Wilcox, I vowed never to be in the same room with him again if I could help it. Fifteen years and many, many rooms later I'm happy that I broke that promise to myself and even happier to discredit both
Emily Post and everyone's grandmother by telling you that first impressions don't mean a thing.
John is best described as wicked cool and wicked smart (if you are hearing me say that in a loud, way-off-the-mark fake Bostonian accent that sounds ever-so-slightly Jamaican, I thank you for knowing me so well). In fact, the only bad thing I can dig up to say about him after all of these years is that he lives entirely too far away from me and pulls off the "crazy old person on a college campus" routine off much better than I do. And that's saying a lot for someone who once drunkenly threw up all over my feet (I picked a terrible day to wear flip-flops but they didn't belong to me, which proves there is always a bright side to everything). Enjoy.
John Wilcox: Why Silver Linings Playbook
Sucks Even Though Jennifer Lawrence (and I Guess Bradley Cooper) is
Ridiculously Good Looking, and Other Stray Observations About Mental Illness
I recently watched Silver Linings Playbook, the movie about
mentally ill people acting zany, rejecting medication, and finding love. It was kind of like A Beautiful Mind 2: Stuck in Philly, or Garden State 2: This Time We Dance.
|
You can tell both characters are suffering from
mental illness from the stubble and constipated expression |
I liked Silver Linings just fine. I, of course, fell a little bit in love with Jennifer Lawrence's character. The Manic Pixie Dream Girl type (defined by Nathan Rabin at The A.V. Club) really does it for me, like Natalie Portman's character in Garden State. I'm a sucker.
But this isn’t about my habit of
falling in love with fictional characters, or even worse, fictional character
types. No, this is about…
…
(the ellipses build suspense)
Mental Illness.
More specifically, this is about
mental illness in movies and the evil atrocity those movies commit (other than
predictability that borders on criminal negligence.)
Of course, a blog about mental
illness wouldn’t be a blog about mental illness without slightly uncomfortable
self-revelation. But that’s kind of the
point of this whole thing. Either by
forming or reflecting cultural values on mental illness, Hollywood has painted such
a consistent portrait of the mentally ill that it is difficult to talk about
without first: 1.) defending mental illnesses as an actual disease and 2.)
explaining away all of the weird stereotypes that almost every movie with a
mentally ill character promotes.
So, some slightly uncomfortable
self-revelation!
Obviously, I wouldn't care about this as much if it didn't somehow affect me personally. About a year after I left the military, I started getting treatment for severe anxiety. The treatment was probably a lifetime overdue, but it became necessary when I spent that first post-military year sitting in my buddy Mark's house doing
absolutely nothing, afraid to make any kind of movement in my life. I didn't go out, I barely reconnected with friends. And I sure as hell didn't make any moves towards my stated goals of going to college.
|
This was pretty much my life for
over a year. Proud time
|
And here is the first part where, often in conversation, I feel like I have to defend myself, rightly or wrongly. I understand that change is scary for everyone. And if you saw my lifestyle for that year, you would probably accuse me of being nothing more than a lazy ass. (I'm always a lazy ass, so that argument is moot.) The fact is, though, that any time I would do something like start the registration process for college or seriously consider a job search, I would get physically ill. Sorry to be gross, but not just a little rumbly in the tumbly, but straight-up puking in the toilet physically ill.
So I decided it was time to get treatment. I went to a psychiatrist who agreed with the diagnosis I had received earlier in the military of severe Generalized Anxiety Disorder with minor depression as a symptom of the anxiety, and started me on a regimen of medication that the hack, useless psychiatrist in the military hadn't bothered to try (and that's a whole other story worth telling sometime, psychiatrists whose primary client is the military rather than the patient. Another day, perhaps.)
Now, the only reason that I'm going to reveal exactly what medication I'm on is because this relates directly to my problem with Silver Linings Playbook and the whole genre of movie it represents. My competent psychiatrist prescribed me Fluoxetine (Prozac) and Clonazepam (Klonopin). I started taking the medication after dealing with severe reservations about taking psychiatric medication. A week after I started taking the medication, I was registered for college, had all of the paperwork filled out correctly with the federal government and Veteran's Affairs (that's a LOT of paperwork), registered for classes, ordered my textbooks, and made contacts on campus. After more than a year of sitting on the couch and doing literally nothing, in a week I accomplised more than I had in the entire year preceding it.
|
I chose my college solely on aesthetic
appeal. Good ol’ St. Scholastica |
And I stayed on the medication for a while, started college and kicked some ass. I was a horrible student in high school, but a straight-A student now in college with very real prospects of getting into a PhD program in the next year. But after being on the medication for more than a year and doing better than I ever have in my thirty years of life, for some reason, I decided to quit. I figured, now that I had a clear idea of what kinds of thoughts were the "mentally ill" thoughts and which ones were my own, I would be able to distinguish between them and only pay attention to the healthy ones. And as stupid as this sounds, and it will probably make you lose respect for me, the reason I thought I could do this was because MOVIES TOLD ME I COULD.
Now hear me out. Every single movie that I can readily think
of has the mentally ill protagonist learn to deal with his or her disease
without the help of medication. And not
only that, the movies I’m thinking of actively demonize medication.
In A Beautiful Mind, mathematician
John Nash (Russel Crowe’s character) deals with severe schizophrenia with
nothing more than willpower and the help of his loving wife. When he is forced into treatment, he loses is
magical mathematical powers, so has to learn to deal with his hallucinations to
be his truly genius self. Of course, in
real life, it was revealed soon after the movie that the real John Nash never
stopped taking his medication, but that was just a minor blip in the news.
Silver Linings Playbook takes it even
a step further and makes the old claim that psychiatric medication turns the
characters into “zombies” and in one scene lists several medications that
countless people rely on to function, and laugh at their horrible effects,
including both medications I took (although I had stopped taking them before I
saw the movie, so it’s wasn’t the movie’s fault I stopped my medication or
anything of the sort.) The movie, along
with almost every other movie that touches on the subject, implies that the
medication somehow fundamentally changes the people for the worse, or robs them
of their “true essence.”
Garden State, One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest, Girl Interrupted, hell
even Good Will Hunting… this is just
off the top of my head. If I thought for
another ten minutes I could probably name another ten movies that demonize
psychiatric medication and treatment.
Think about all of the scenes of wily characters squirreling their
medication in their cheeks only to dispose of it later.
So with this cultural context
firmly embedded in my skull, I had stopped the medication that had so
dramatically improved my life. And guess
what happened? Life started sucking
again. I was missing assignments, and towards
the end of the semester I started getting physically ill again when I tried to
leave my apartment. I started
contemplating dropping out of college because I couldn’t handle what was
happening.
Thankfully, some of the contacts I have made on campus are truly Good People,
and one of them helped me get back to treatment before the end of the
semester. And again, just like the first
time, a week after I re-started the medication I went into kick-ass overdrive,
caught up with almost a full semester’s worth of work, and somehow scraped by
the end of the semester maintaining above a 3.75 GPA. And even though that was the worst I had done
so far in college (totally bragging, unabashedly,) I had never been
prouder.
I guess this is the point,
finally. If you have never dealt with
mental illness, or if you are dealing with it now and refusing medication
because you are afraid it will make you a different person, don’t believe the
movies.
Now, getting on the right medication is often a long process for people
suffering from mental illnesses. And
sometimes, the medications they try have negative effects like making that
person feel sluggish and slow, or disassociated. But that’s just because it’s the wrong
medication. Not every medication does
that to every person. Getting treatment
for mental illness is not wrong somehow, it does not make you weak, taking
medication isn’t a sign of defeat. And
not only that, but sometimes, medication is absolutely
totally necessary to successful treatment of mental diseases.
Because that’s exactly what we’re
talking about. Treating diseases. Real diseases. And that gets me to my last little minor
point with this beast.
One thing I realized as an adult
dealing with a mental illness is that I have to be open and honest about the
whole thing. Don’t get me wrong, I don’t
usually advertise it (other than, you know, this blog or whatever,) and it is
not a common topic of conversation in my everyday life. But it sometimes is necessary to bring
up. In my academic life, I have found it
much easier to be honest with my professors about what is happening than trying
to hide it, because even on medication there are some bad days (very very few,
but some.) And predictably, the
reactions differ. Almost all of the
professors accept what I tell them, perhaps ask some questions, and we move
on. However, there are the few people
that, although they nod, I can tell think that I am just another person making
an excuse. That “mental illness” is just
another word for “lazy” or “disorganized” or whatever it may be.
And I guess that is any
individual’s right to believe what he or she chooses to believe, but I’m pretty
sure that medical science has gone pretty far to prove that mental illnesses
are real and identifiable. Diseases to
be treated. I’m no expert, but I’m
pretty sure the experts agree that mental illnesses are real. But some people think that billions of people
emitting noxious gases doesn’t affect the atmosphere, so you can’t expect
everyone to accept mental illness either.
So even though it is very uncomfortable to talk about sometimes, if
someone suffers from some random physical disease, let’s just say Lupus for the
hell of it, she may not like talking about it, but if it interferes with her
life, she is probably not too hesitant to explain what is happening. (And the feminine pronoun isn’t just culturally
progressive, but accurate to Lupus because that’s how I roll.) And that’s how I have to look at my own
illness. If it gets in the way of a
successful life, I need to explain what’s happening.
And to wrap a bow on it, I can’t
think of any movie that demonizes treatment for physical diseases. So stop it, Hollywood. You’re fucking people up by promoting this
idea that treatment is bad. It’s a
goddamn disease. Get treatment. Don’t be afraid to talk about it. Even though those movies pretend to be “sympathetic”
to mental illness, they are a bunch of crap.
I suppose that's it. I've been thinking a lot about mental illness advocacy. I don't know. Just something on my mind. My recent struggle with medication (and lack thereof) and then watching Silver Linings Playbook made me realize that there is a lot of work to be done with de-stimatization. I guess this is my opening salvo. We'll see where I go from here.
|
Yes I did. |